designworkplan


Signage and color contrast

by Sander Baumann. Average Reading Time: about 7 minutes.

Within sig­nage & wayfind­ing design the way of color and con­trast are impor­tant fac­tors to effec­tively com­mu­ni­cate a mes­sage. Col­ors have dif­fer­ent mean­ings and work in var­i­ous ways in con­trast together. This arti­cle will explain the mean­ing of color and will show var­i­ous exam­ples of contrast.

Con­trast between the fore­ground and back­ground is one of the most impor­tant fac­tors for the ease of read­ing. If coloured text is used on a bright back­ground the con­trast will be weak, for opti­mal con­trast results is white text against dark col­ored back­grounds. In sig­nage & wayfind­ing design color is the com­bin­ing fac­tor to har­mo­nize the sign with the envi­ron­ment. Color pro­grams will dis­tin­guish signs from each other and can offer an indi­ca­tion of the mes­sage with­out hav­ing to be able to under­stand the lan­guage of the sign.

Basics of color groups: Color wheel

farbkreis_itten_1961Swiss painter and designer Johannes Itten cre­ated a color wheel that is a orga­ni­za­tion of 12 color hues around in a cir­cle show­ing rela­tion­ships between the col­ors. The col­ors are pre­sented in the fol­low­ing way:

  • Pri­mary col­ors: Blue, red & yellow
  • Sec­ondary col­ors: Green, orange & violet
  • Com­ple­men­tary col­ors: Red–orange, red–violet, yellow–orange, yellow–green, blue–violet & blue–green.

Most color wheels are based on Goethe’s The­ory of Colours, the first sys­tem­atic study of the phys­i­o­log­i­cal effects of color (1810). His obser­va­tions on the effect of opposed col­ors led him to a sym­met­ric arrange­ment of his color wheel, “for the colours dia­met­ri­cally opposed to each other… are those which rec­i­p­ro­cally evoke each other in the eye.” (via wikipedia)

The color wheel can be a basis for the color scheme for the design you are about to cre­ate. Using the wheel you can eas­ily find the com­bi­na­tions between the col­ors and see what works best. See the oppo­site col­ors and com­bine the col­ors into a sig­nage color scheme.

Mean­ing of color

  • color-blackBlack is not actu­ally a color but is often used as back­ground sur­face in sign design, black can offer a attrac­tion in a visual crowed envi­ron­ment. Mean­ing of black: Black is asso­ci­ated with power, ele­gance, for­mal­ity, death, evil, and mystery.
  • color-whiteWhite as back­ground sur­face has the abil­ity to absorb dark let­ter­ing into its sur­round­ings, in order to make white work good in sign design use a mat­ted sur­face with glossy let­ter­ing. Mean­ing of white: White is asso­ci­ated with light, good­ness, inno­cence, purity, and vir­gin­ity. It is con­sid­ered to be the color of perfection.
  • color-redRed is a sig­nal color, as back­ground red is mostly used for warn­ing signs. Mean­ing of red: Red is the color of fire and blood, so it is asso­ci­ated with energy, war, dan­ger, strength, power, deter­mi­na­tion as well as pas­sion, desire, and love.
  • color-yellowYel­low in sign design is used as back­ground, yel­low has a func­tion of send­ing out a mes­sage and works good in a spa­cial envi­ron­ment, it stands out. Mean­ing of yel­low: Yel­low is the color of sun­shine. It’s asso­ci­ated with joy, hap­pi­ness, intel­lect, and energy.
  • color-blueBlue is one of mankind favourite color, but for design blue will not always have the best results, try using var­i­ous hues of blue to find the best match­ing results. Mean­ing of blue: Blue is the color of the sky and sea. It is often asso­ci­ated with depth and sta­bil­ity. It sym­bol­izes trust, loy­alty, wis­dom, con­fi­dence, intel­li­gence, faith, truth, and heaven.
  • Resource the mean­ing of color fur­ther on this page.

Black back­ground

contrast-blackIn sign & wayfind­ing design con­trast will let you read the signs at ease. Below you will find var­i­ous exam­ples of good and bad con­trast in order to make the design work.

With a black back­ground the let­ter­ing tends to stand out more onto to back­ground than with other col­ored back­grounds. Black is one of the few sur­faces that lets other col­ored text work great together. Beware of too small let­ter­ing with too high con­trast (white let­ter­ing), these will lead to less leg­i­bil­ity of the text because of over­whelm­ing back­ground. With large let­ter­ing white on black works great. Also yel­low on black is a good combination.

Advis­able work areas: Air­port sig­nage, office build­ing signs, visual over­whelm­ing envi­ron­ments, hotel sig­nage, indoor usage.

White back­ground

contrast-blackWhite back­ground sur­face gives the most work­able com­bi­na­tions, but beware of that white can absorb its envi­ron­ment. Black let­ter­ing tends to be squeezed into the back­ground mak­ing it hard to read. Lower con­trast let­ter­ing gives bet­ter results like blue, orange and red.

White back­grounds can be used spe­cific sign projects where design plays a big­ger part than the actual wayfind­ing. For instance using sil­ver let­ter­ing on a white back­ground can give fab­u­lous results, due the shadow of the sil­ver let­ter­ing the text becomes read­able on the white surface.

Advis­able work areas: Museum sig­nage, office build­ing signs, pylon sig­nage, retail sig­nage, hos­pi­tal sig­nage, indoor & out­door usage.

Yel­low background

contrast-yellowYel­low back­ground works best in visual crowded envi­ron­ments, for archi­tec­tural and psy­cho­log­i­cal fac­tors yel­low is often used. Yel­low with black let­ter­ing sends out a clear infor­ma­tion mes­sage which is needed in such an envi­ron­ment. Using yel­low also makes in easy to use orange, red and green which all work great together in a sig­nage system.

Yel­low is a much used back­ground color for air­port sig­nage, orig­i­nally started by Paul Mijk­se­naar for Schiphol Air­port sig­nage, nowa­days yel­low is seen in many air­ports around the world. Yel­low in com­bi­na­tion with black let­ter­ing gives ease to read and at the same time a clear infor­ma­tion mes­sage in its surroundings.

Also for traf­fic signs yel­low works good as back­ground color in com­bi­na­tion with black let­ter­ing. In a out­door sit­u­a­tion, yel­low stands out from its back­ground giv­ing a clear mes­sage. In many Euro­pean coun­tries yel­low is cho­sen as back­ground color.

Advis­able work areas: Air­port sig­nage, road signs, pub­lic spaces, indoor & out­door usage.

Red back­ground

contrast-redRed is often used for warn­ing signs, red sends out a sig­nal of warn­ing, dan­ger. Many of the warn­ing signs con­sist of a red back­ground with yel­low or white let­ter­ing, by using pic­tograms as warn­ing the signs are multi-language and don’t need expla­na­tion, even if you can­not read the text.

Red is a very pow­er­ful color which stands out in a visual crowded envi­ron­ment. I have seen var­i­ous other signs pro­duced with red but in my opin­ion red is a sig­nal color. Works great with black, white and yel­low lettering.

Advis­able work areas: Warn­ing signs, pub­lic spaces, indoor & out­door usage.

Blue back­ground

contrast-blueBlue is one of mankind favourite color, as is rep­re­sents sky, heaven, trust and faith. The color blue is good rec­og­nized with white let­ter­ing as infor­ma­tion sign. In the Nether­lands all high­way signs are with blue back­ground as well as the rail­way signs.

To use blue in sign sys­tems beware of cre­ate enough con­trast in order to make the signs work best. For instance with light blue a higher con­trast let­ter­ing will be needed such as black and for dark blue white let­ter­ing will work best.

Advis­able work areas: High­way signs, rail­way signs, hotel sig­nage, retail sig­nage, pub­lic spaces, indoor & out­door usage.

Pur­ple background

contrast-purplePur­ple will not be your direct usage of back­ground color for sig­nage color sys­tems, but pur­ple is a fash­ion color which is asked by clients to use. Pur­ple works great with lighter col­ored let­ter­ing such as white or yellow.

Pur­ple can be used in sig­nage sys­tems but beware of its archi­tec­tural envi­ron­ment, as pur­ple is a very pow­er­ful color it can eas­ily fade into the back­ground mak­ing the sign unreadable.

Use the color wheel to cre­ate the hue of col­ors around the color pur­ple. Pur­ple rep­re­sents roy­alty and spir­i­tu­al­ity, it was Pan­tones color of the year 2008. PANTONE® 18–3943 BLUE IRIS.

Advis­able work areas: Museum sig­nage, hotel sig­nage, retail sig­nage, indoor usage.

Sil­ver (brushed) background

contrast-silverSil­ver (metal) is an often used color as back­ground in sign sys­tems. With metal signs you are able to gain a robust look & feel for the sig­nage sys­tem. Metal has a dif­fer­ent sur­face when look­ing at it from dif­fer­ent angles, mak­ing it not always a good con­trast with the lettering.

On a sil­ver back­ground almost all col­ors work well, even white. In future arti­cles I will go deeper into using sil­ver as background.

Metal signs are fre­quently used in office sig­nage, with black let­ter­ing it will cre­ate a very styl­ish look and feel.

Advis­able work areas: Office sig­nage, name­plate design, pub­lic spaces, indoor & out­door usage.

Typog­ra­phy & color contrast

Not only is the con­trast impor­tant also the cho­sen type­face will make the dif­fer­ence in a good or bad sign. When using too bold weighted type­faces the text will look like its expand­ing of the sign, when using too light weighted type­faces the text will fall back into its back­ground. Medium or Reg­u­lar weights are usu­ally the best options to choose for a good and read­able sign.

Please share your thoughts

What do you find the most attractive/readable col­ored back­ground?
Look­ing for­ward dis­cussing about col­ors & signs! Thank you in advance.



39 comments on ‘Signage and color contrast’

  1. Undrln

    Story added…

    Your story was fea­tured in Undrln! Here is the link to vote it up and pro­mote it: http://undrln.com/All/Signage-design-and-color-contrast...

  2. Rob Chant

    Very use­ful post, thanks

    It may be worth not­ing that mean­ings and asso­ci­a­tions we have with colour are very depen­dent on cul­ture. For a Chi­nese per­son, for exam­ple, the asso­ci­a­tions, with, say, the colour red, may be very dif­fer­ent than our own.

  3. Frank

    Wow! Nice arti­cle. Never noticed al those colours in the signs around me, but now I prob­a­bly will.

  4. Vincent

    Well writ­ten arti­cle, I will use this infor­ma­tion to com­mu­ni­cate my choices for colors.

  5. Sander Baumann

    Thanks Rob Chant — for your com­ment. You are totally cor­rect, all col­ors have dif­fer­ent mean­ings in dif­fer­ent cultures.

    Mean­ing of red

    • Euro­pean : Dan­ger (stop signs), love (hearts), excite­ment (for sale signs)
    • China : Tra­di­tional bridal colour, good luck, cel­e­bra­tion, hap­pi­ness, joy, vital­ity, long life, sum­mon­ing, the direc­tion South. Chi­nese say­ing goes “when some­thing is so red, it is pur­ple” — red pur­ple brings luck and fame.
    • South Africa : Mourning
    • Aus­tralian abo­rig­i­nals : the land, earth, cer­e­mo­nial ochre

    Source.

    This is a photo of a typ­i­cal warn­ing sign (US/European)

    Here is a photo of a Chi­nese warn­ing sign

    Although the Chi­nese photo is not very sharp you can still notice the red cir­cles around the pro­hib­ited icons. There­fore I strongly believe for warn­ing sig­nage, red is the color used all over the world. Thanks again for your com­ment, appreciated!

    Thanks Frank & Vin­cent — for your com­ments, very appreciated.

  6. tag cloud at this site demon­strates the bad con­trast of col­ors.
    it (in a cloud of tags) is used for rank­ing the font size and color. tags used by a small amount of time, almost to merge with the back­ground (very dif­fi­cult to read them).

  7. Sander Baumann

    Hi Николай Громов (nicothin) — Thank you for your insight, I believe you have a point there, a bit offtopic to the arti­cle but com­ment noted.

  8. Rob Chant

    Sander, thanks for the feed­back. You’re prob­a­bly right about red being a fairly uni­ver­sal warn­ing colour.

    Regard­ing your tag cloud, I think it works well how it is now. Obvi­ously the lesser used tags do fall into the back­ground, but surely that’s the point?

  9. Jin

    I’m glad Rob brought up the cul­ture dif­fer­ences here. Red in China, is as you described in your com­ment. How­ever red is never used for writ­ing a person’s name. Because in the old times, the war­den would write names of pris­on­ers who are to be exe­cuted in red.

  10. Josef Go-Oco

    Very use­ful post, thanks! I’m doing okay with my blog – I just don’t have time to make con­tent because of school stuff, and I’m plan­ning on buy­ing host­ing and domain, so I’m also with­hold­ing.
    Any­way, I believe cul­tural dif­fer­ences on the inter­pre­ta­tion of color can be dis­solved eas­ily with mul­ti­cul­tural waves about us, famil­iar­iz­ing gen­er­a­tions with the global ‘stan­dard’, thereby rein­forc­ing their roles as stan­dards. Such is the effect of globalization.

  11. Rob Chant

    cul­tural dif­fer­ences… can be dis­solved eas­ily with mul­ti­cul­tural waves about us”

    It would be a sad, sad day that this comes to pass.

  12. Josef Go-Oco

    Very much so. Out of the topic, but if a nation with a weak national iden­tity – or one that has not found its own iden­tity – has been exposed to a cul­ture of mul­ti­cul­tur­al­ism, then I’m afraid it would lose its ground and be afloat with its hodge­podge of cultures.

  13. […] Sig­nage & Color Con­trast - A brief, sim­ple expla­na­tion of col­ors and how to match them up. […]

  14. Mark Denton

    Nicely done, Sander. I like the dis­cus­sion of what the dif­fer­ent col­ors con­note. I think we often take this into con­sid­er­a­tion in an intu­itive man­ner when design­ing sig­nage sys­tems, but I don’t think I have really seen the mean­ings spelled out like this before.

    You’re right about yel­low being a more com­mon back­ground color in Europe. I don’t see it used nearly as much here in the U.S.

  15. Sander Baumann

    Thank you all for the input, much appreciated!

  16. […] Sig­nage & wayfind­ing design, choose the right color Good explina­tion of col­ors! (tags: web­de­sign design infor­ma­tion color doc­u­men­ta­tion colour) […]

  17. tulsa signs

    The dis­cus­sion on color (hue) is inter­est­ing.
    How­ever, the pri­mary impor­tance of color on a sign is its value in rela­tion to the back­ground.
    All col­ors should be con­verted to their respec­tive gray scale so their actual value can be seen.

    In most sign design, the pri­mary copy should have the great­est value con­trast to its back­ground.
    (light on dark, dark on light)
    The sec­ondary copy should have less of a value contrast.

    Just look at any land­scape image that shows moun­tains in the dis­tance.
    There is a fore­ground, mid­dle ground and back­ground.
    Signs should be the same.

  18. kovshenin

    Cool, thanks this may come in handy…

  19. Jenny Pilley

    It is inter­est­ing to see how this can relate to web designs. The colours and con­trasts can make dif­fer­ent com­pany trades more sus­cep­ti­ble to use some colours with oth­ers. With the dif­fer­ent text on the plain colours it is easy to which colours go together and those that should be avoided. Excel­lent information.

  20. Hendry

    Dear All,

    My name is Hendry Soetardjo Nanuru. I am a 4th year stu­dent in Visual Com­mu­ni­ca­tion Design at Insti­tut Teknologi Hara­pan Bangsa, Ban­dung — Indone­sia. Cur­rently I am writ­ing my the­sis to fin­ish my study in Visual Com­mu­ni­ca­tion Design.

    I am really inter­ested in Dutch graphic design. The sim­ple form, great con­cepts, free expres­sion and explo­ration, make Dutch design good. So I took Dutch design as the topic of my thesis.

    The topic of my the­sis is about the use of “Col­ors in Dutch Design”.

    I would like to know why many Dutch design­ers are really con­fi­dent to use colours in their design? Maybe there are also other rea­sons that make Dutch design­ers are con­fi­dent to use color.

    Would you like to advice me, which books are related with my topic? It is quite dif­fi­cult for me to find infor­ma­tion about a good books. I bought already some books; Dutch Graphic Design (Cen­tury of inno­va­tion), False Flat, and Design van de 20ste eeuw, but there is still not enough expla­na­tion about “colour in Dutch design”.

    I appre­ci­ate your help, and thank you in advance.

    Kind regards,

    Hendry

  21. Javier

    This is good mate­r­ial very use­ful, thanks

  22. Hendry

    Hi Javier,

    Thank you.
    Are you dutch? Do you know any ducth peo­ple here, and may I make an inter­view with you or them by skype?

    Thank you for your help.

    Kind regards,
    Hendry

  23. Sander Baumann

    Thank you Hendry Soetardjo Nanuru — for your com­ment. I will send you an email so when can dis­cuss more about color and Dutch designers.

  24. Javier

    hello hendry thank you very much send me your ques­tions to my email.

  25. Ngoc Thuy

    thanks a lot, they are really clear and help­ful for my design course ^^

  26. Hendry

    Hi all,
    Any dutch designer here? Is it pos­si­ble if I make an inter­view with one of you guys?
    I need your help to fin­ish my thesis.

    Please just let me know.

    Thank you in advance.

    Regards,
    Hendry

  27. Jonathan

    Sander,

    Your arti­cle is a good start for a seri­ous conversation.

    As noted by other read­ers, the colour mean­ings you describe are some­what arbi­trary and very generic. I realise you were aim­ing to sum up more com­plex issues, but I believe that in the area of wayfind­ing and sig­nage design gen­er­alised advice can lead to frus­tra­tion and even acci­dents. When describ­ing colour con­trast and colour mean­ing, it is impor­tant to speak of ‘a blue’ and not just of ‘blue’, for exam­ple Navy blue or Marine blue, both of which elicit quite a dif­fer­ent emo­tional response and achieve a dif­fer­ent colour con­trast with other colours.

    Cer­tain colours have explicit mean­ings and uses. These are pre­scribed by inter­na­tional and local stan­dards and build­ing codes. For exam­ple refer to ISO 7010:2003.

    White back­ground tends to reflect light and gen­er­ate glare, which dimin­ishes leg­i­bil­ity, even when using matt sur­face fin­ish. Unless you are using a com­bi­na­tion of text size and thick­ness that com­pen­sates for this, it is advis­able to avoid white background.

    When dis­cussing which colours to use, one must con­sider the phys­i­cal con­text of the sign, as you sug­gest your­self. Not only do you need to have good con­trast between text and back­ground colour, but also sign back­ground and the envi­ron­ment in which it is placed, or you start hav­ing peo­ple bump­ing into sign structures.

    Another cru­cial aspect to con­sider in the con­text of ‘sig­nage and colour con­trast’ is colour-blindness. A colour com­bi­na­tion that may seem to have suf­fi­cient con­trast for peo­ple with full colour vision may not be suit­able for all.

  28. darshini

    jonathan,

    i am con­tent and moti­vated after read­ing your write up.
    i agree that there can­not be any gen­er­al­iza­tion in design or design prin­ci­ples.
    i am a space designer work­ing on a sig­nage project for India Habi­tat Cen­tre, New Delhi, India.
    i am equipped with design skills but need whole lot of info on “Sig­nage design” and prefer­ably the design process that follows.

    does every­thing at the end of the day boil down to — “what suits the eye of the viewer”

  29. AKY

    Very help­ful. Thanks!

  30. Грамотно написано, но мне кажется, что автор что-то не договаривает :)

  31. […] 4, 2009 Spul­ciando tra i post di Design­work­plan seg­nalo due inter­es­santi post sul wayfind­ing: 1– Sig­nage and color con­trast 2– Air­port Sig­nage: Photo […]

  32. What do colors mean?

    […] Sig­nage & Color Con­trast – A brief, sim­ple expla­na­tion of col­ors and how to match them up. […]

  33. Muripshaka Yibis

    Thougt­fully and prac­ti­cally writ­ten! I am really impressed and this arti­cle has added alot to how much i know of colour appli­ca­tion in prac­ti­cal usage.

  34. […] tomado y tra­ducido libre­mente del sitio: design­work­plan Com­parte este […]

  35. […] Sig­nage and color contrast […]

  36. Schedule

    You you should change the web­page name title design­work­plan » Sig­nage and color con­trast to more spe­cific for your blog post you cre­ate. I loved the post all the same.

  37. Sinan Turpekici

    Hi Sander,
    You know that it’s used White let­ter­ing on Blue Sig­nage in Istan­bul Ataturk Air­port. i think it’s con­nected with the archi­tec­tural con­struc­tion that it belongs. If you use dif­fer­ent or uncon­ve­nient col­ors in the build­ing, it seems absurd and unre­al­ized…
    What would you say about that?
    Thanks…

  38. […] recent post titled “Sig­nage and color con­trast” on the blog Design Work Plan (dwp) did a really nice job of explain­ing the basics of color and […]

  39. Zei

    Great job!! Such a great post. Thank you very much.

Leave a Reply