designworkplan


[Review] The Smashing Book

by Sander Baumann. Average Reading Time: about 5 minutes.

Smash­ing Mag­a­zine one of the best design blogs on the inter­net, known for its lists of inspi­ra­tion, design exam­ples and tuto­ri­als recently pub­lished a book, The Smash­ing Book. At the web­site smash­ing mag­a­zine the com­mu­nity had deci­sions on the top­ics for the book, a new way of get­ting the poten­tial read­ers into this book. The authors of Smash­ing Mag­a­zine com­bined forces and wrote this great book.

The Smash­ing Book

The Smashing Book
In sum­mary the book is about every­thing you need to know to cre­ate web­sites, from design, typog­ra­phy, lay­out, color usage, inter­face design, cod­ing, brand­ing, web-development and much much more. At the end of the book is an inter­est­ing topic; Learn­ing from experts, which includes inter­views and insights on com­mon top­ics when design­ing and cre­at­ing web­sites. The last chap­ter is the Smash­ing Mag­a­zine Story, Sven Lennartz and Vitaly Fried­man go deeper into how Smash­ing started and where it is today and in the future.

The first pages show the table of con­tents which is a bit to short for me, head­lines only. What inter­ests me is what I can learn at the chap­ters of the book. If I want to use this book as ref­er­ence guide when work­ing on a project I quickly need to find the infor­ma­tion and how I can learn from that. Here’s mine inter­pre­ta­tion of what you will learn from The Smash­ing Book.

The Smashing Book

The Smashing Book

1. User inter­face design in mod­ern web applications

Dmitry Fadeyev talks about the the­ory as well as the prac­ti­cal tech­niques involved in visual inter­face design, start­ing with the basics char­ac­ter­is­tics of inter­face design to how infor­ma­tion is adapted com­bined with many examples.

2. The art and sci­ence of CSS-Layouts

Jacob Gube and Kayla Knight go deeper into the need and basics design­ing web­sites in CSS lay­outs. They dis­cuss four types of lay­outs: fixed-width, fluid, elas­tic and hybrid, all accom­pa­nied by exam­ples and DIY CSS code. In con­clu­sion they give well advise on what to choose for your next web design.

3.(Web) Typog­ra­phy: Rules, guide­lines and com­mon mistakes

This chap­ter describes meth­ods and tech­niques for typog­ra­phy on the web and what char­ac­ter­is­tics are best prac­tice for (large) con­tent web­sites in read­abil­ity, line length and line height as well as a short typo­graph­i­cal terms index. The chap­ter goes deeper into the bal­ance in typog­ra­phy within design, place­ment and leg­i­bil­ity, with exam­ples and most pop­u­lar type­faces avail­able. Fur­ther on in this chap­ter the authors Alessan­dro Cat­te­neo, Yves Peters and Jon Tan talks about text replace­ment tech­niques and how that can ben­e­fit your design. Great read!

4. Usabil­ity prin­ci­ples for Mod­ern Websites

Andrew Maier and David Leggett takes it deeper into the prin­ci­ples of an usable web­site design by set­ting out the char­ac­ter­is­tics on what is impor­tant and to whom it con­cerns. This chap­ter is accom­pa­nied by many exam­ples and prac­ti­cal tips to cre­ate an usable web­site design.

5. The ulti­mate guide to fan­tas­tic color usage in web design, usabil­ity and experience

What an enor­mous title Dar­ius A Mon­sef IV came up with, any­way this chap­ter tells you about color in web design. This chap­ter is full of exam­ples and color wheels but it is not really learn­ing you any­thing about color or how to use color wheels in web­site design.

6. Per­for­mance opti­miza­tion for websites

Rene Schmidt tells about tech­niques on how to improve the web­site per­for­mance with short and prac­ti­cal exam­ples. A bit too tech­ni­cal for me.

7. Design to sell, increas­ing con­ver­sion rates

Dmitry Fadeyev wrote this great chap­ter on focus and place­ment. With prac­ti­cal tips the author talks about the AIDA sales fun­nel and how to get web­site vis­i­tors into buy­ing some­thing from your website.

8. How to turn a site into a remark­able brand

Chris Spooner takes it step by step in how to cre­ate a web­site that sticks… With many exam­ples and prin­ci­ples this chap­ter tells you how to cre­ate your own brand.

Learn­ing from the experts: Inter­views and Insights

The Smashing Book
Steven Snell got together with over 20 expert design­ers and devel­op­ers to share their knowl­edge and phi­los­o­phy in design top­ics. The panel dis­cusses the fol­low­ing top­ics design & devel­op­ment, the design process, self improve­ment and skill devel­op­ment and busi­ness and free­lanc­ing. A true gem of the Smash­ing­book where design­ers give their opin­ion and prac­ti­cal tips on the process. Every­thing wrote in a very acces­si­ble way. #mustread

Behind the cur­tains: The Smash­ing Mag­a­zine Story

The last chap­ter is devoted to the Smash­ing Story, Sven Lennartz and Vitaly Fried­man talks about the start up of The Smash­ing Mag­a­zine and how every­thing evolved to where SM is today.

Book vs online

The Smashing Book
The Smash­ing Mag­a­zine (online) is a great resource of infor­ma­tion when you are into learn­ing design, typog­ra­phy and inspi­ra­tion. The book is a reflec­tion of the online infor­ma­tion but more in an edu­ca­tional man­ner and you will pick up the book more likely to learn some­thing and use it effec­tively. With online media you quickly scan the pages and move on, there­fore I believe the book will be a huge improve­ment for spread­ing knowl­edge and will become a spring­board for those who are inter­ested in this field.

I hope SM will con­tinue to pub­lish the great online con­tent and start series of Smash­ing books with prac­ti­cal learn­ing content.

Hard­ware qual­ity and size of the book

The Smashing Book
After two weeks of intense read­ing the Smash­ing­book seems to fall apart, the binder is very though, this makes it hard to open pages and lay the book beside the com­puter to type in the exam­ple code or check a ref­er­ence online. To my opin­ion the book is a bit too small for its con­tent, great con­tent but it doesn’t read very easy. I would sug­gest for future books to use a larger book size, less pages and more white space on the pages.

Con­clu­sion

The Smash­ing Book is a great, really great book for every­body who is inter­ested in design and web-development. Espe­cially the typog­ra­phy and learn­ing from the experts chap­ters where inspi­ra­tional resources to me. The con­tent is great but I believe the lay­out of the pages should be as a book. Sup­port the Smash­ing Mag­a­zine Book by order­ing your copy and I hope SM will con­tinue the con­cept of bring­ing the con­tent by book.

Avail­abil­ity of The Smash­ing Book

Cur­rently the Smash­ing Book is avail­able through the SM web­site shop for $29,90 or €23,90 and pay­ment is processed with many avail­able options such as cred­it­card and paypal.

  • Spec­i­fi­ca­tions: size 210 x 140 mm, full color high qual­ity, 311 pages, pub­lished by Smash­ing Media GmbH, Lübeck Ger­many 2009
  • Get the SM Book here: The Smash­ing Book is released: Buy Now!

Did you buy they book, please share your opin­ion about the Smash­ing Book in the com­ments, thank you in advance!



29 comments on ‘[Review] The Smashing Book’

  1. […] This post was men­tioned on Twit­ter by Design­Work­Plan, wkempf. wkempf said: RT @designworkplan: [blog­post] Book review: The Smash­ing Book http://bit.ly/smbook @smashingmag […]

  2. Undrln

    Story added…

    Your story was fea­tured in Undrln! Here is the link to vote it up and pro­mote it: http://www.undrln.com/All/Book-Review-The-Smashing-Book...

  3. designmoo.com

    Story added to Designmoo.com…

    This was fea­tured in designmoo.com! Here is the link to vote it up and pro­mote it: http://designmoo.com/node/15688...

  4. [Book Review] The Smash­ing Book…

    A full review of The Smash­ing Book, find out more about this book for design and web-development.…

  5. zabox.net

    [Book Review] The Smash­ing Book…

    A full review of already famous Smash­ing Book, find out all about this book for design and web-development.…

  6. designfloat.com

    [Book Review] The Smash­ing Book…

    A full review of the famous Smash­ing Book about design and web-development.…

  7. Vince

    Nice review Sander, great descrip­tions about the chap­ters. I love read­ing the book to get some more indepth infor­ma­tion about the work I do. Makes it that much eas­ier to explain it all to my clients and myself, hehe.

    On a side note; they really did dis­ap­point me with their deliv­ery times. From pre-order to actual deliv­ery was like 5 months, ridiculous.

  8. favSHARE

    This arti­cle has been shared on favSHARE.net. Go and vote it!

  9. uberVU - social comments

    Social com­ments and ana­lyt­ics for this post…

    This post was men­tioned on Twit­ter by design­work­plan: [blog­post] Book review: The Smash­ing Book http://bit.ly/smbook @smashingmag…

  10. Sander Baumann

    Thanks Vince — for your com­ment. I agree with you on the wait­ing time, but some­times some ele­ments are out of direct con­trol in order to live up to the expec­ta­tions. Good to hear you are using the book in a pro­fes­sional man­ner, good luck and happy holidays.

  11. Derek

    Next time, have some­one else write the arti­cle. It reads hor­ri­ble. Typos and errors rid­dle this page.

  12. Dan Grossman

    Got my copy in the mail (after months of wait­ing as well) but haven’t started read­ing it. It’s so poorly designed from a pub­lish­ing stand­point that it turns me off from want­ing to. You have to apply so much force just to hold the book open wide enough to read any­thing, the text is too small, and the thick­ness of the paper and size of the book make it impos­si­ble to straighten out the pages while read­ing. They’re always curved towards the binding.

  13. Michael

    I’d review mine, but I have yet to actu­ally receive it, you know, after nearly a month after it shipped, and a few months after it was ordered.

    Com­plete lack of pro­fes­sion­al­ism and fore­thought by Smash­ing Mag­a­zine team, and they’ll receive no such fur­ther sup­port from me.

  14. Vin Thomas

    I thought the same thing about the book falling apart. I like how the “Dig Into Word­Press” book that was just released in print is done in spi­ral bind­ing. It might not be as pretty, but at least it won’t fall apart.

    Even still I want to get this book.

  15. George

    The entire book project, from front to back, shows that the cre­ators know a lot about online pre­sen­ta­tion and pro­duc­tion, but rather lit­tle about print media.

    All the delays, which print design­ers nor­mally know to be aware of, pushed back their “antic­i­pated” ship date by months.

    The book is set in a sans-serif font … which is nor­mally ideal for web, with its ~72 dpi res­o­lu­tion, but with print media > 300 dpi, ser­ifs really make print mat­ter more com­fort­able for the eye to read.

    Also, in web, you nor­mally make mar­gins mir­rored. It’s just obvi­ous. But, with printed books, perfect-bound and other meth­ods, mir­rored mar­gins are the way to go. You want to give the inner mar­gin a larger amount of space than the outer, so that the reader doesn’t need to break the bind­ing of the book, in order to read what’s on the inner part of the page.

    All in all, I am quite con­tent with the con­tent (Grade: A+), and quite embar­rassed by the pre­sen­ta­tion (Grade: C).

  16. George

    Edit: Also, in web, you nor­mally don’t make mar­gins mirrored.

  17. Rob

    Thanks for review­ing. I’d like to com­ment on it also but like so many oth­ers I still haven’t recieved my copy, and as a reg­u­lar reader of their web­site I’m not that excited about get­ting the book as it sounds like I’ll have read most of what’s in the book already.

  18. Alex Blundell

    Thanks for the review. It’s speared me on to actu­ally read mine. I’ve opened it once but not read any of it due to the redicu­lous size of the book.

    I thought it would at least be A4/letter size. It’s a pain in the ass to keep the book open.

    I’m sure though that the con­tents will be great though… when I read it

  19. Cousin Vinny

    Nice review. Like other com­men­ta­tors here, I haven’t received my copy yet. :( I’m in the U.S., btw. Kinda dis­ap­point­ing, as I was hop­ing to read the book dur­ing my win­ter break before I return to work.

  20. kirkoconnor

    I am eagerly await­ing my copy but a bit sur­prised now that they didn’t research the printed book issues more thoroughly.

    Isn’t that why we are all buy­ing the book — to make sure we thor­oughly research the web con­tent design thoroughly ?

    Per­haps they need to eat their own dog­food to quote a Google phrase !

  21. Design Informer

    Really nice book review. I’m still work­ing on fin­ish­ing the book and I plan on writ­ing a review as well. I def­i­nitely agree with you about the size. I would love to see a big­ger font and a big­ger book.

    A good idea is what Chris Coyier did with his recent book. He made it have a spi­ral bind­ing. This would have been excel­lent to have for the SmashingBook.

  22. Sander, thank you very much for the objec­tive and pro­fes­sional review. You indeed pro­vided a very exten­sive overview of the book, its con­tent and its qual­ity. Thank you for you time.

    @Vince, @Dan Gross­man, @Alex Blun­dell: we are aware that the whole ship­ping delays story was a big dis­ap­point­ment, it def­i­nitely dam­aged our rep­u­ta­tion and we will have to regain it in 2010. We are aware that we made some unpro­fes­sional mis­takes with the print, and we will do our best to make sure that next edi­tions of the Smash­ing Book are pro­fes­sional from the tra­di­tional print pub­lish­ing stand­point. 5 months was indeed a ridicu­lously long wait­ing time and we are aware that it was also our fault. We are already work­ing on some improve­ments to make sure that it won’t hap­pen again.

    How­ever, we think that we did a quite good job in terms of edi­to­r­ial and con­tent. There are some light typ­ing errors in the Table of con­tents, but apart from that the con­tent should be a gold­mine for design­ers and developers.

    @Vin Thomas: your point ic valid, how­ever you need to under­stand that our goal was to make the book afford­able for every­body world­wide. $67 for print+pdf (“Dig­ging into Word­Press”) is a price that most devel­op­ers from India can not afford. It was very impor­tant for us to keep the price as low as pos­si­ble. Unfor­tu­nately, the result was that the bind­ing wasn’t appro­pri­ate. How­ever, we will improve the bind­ing in the sec­ond edition.

    @Design Informer: a spi­ral bind­ing would dras­ti­cally increase the price of the Smash­ing Book, and we didn’t want it to be expensive.

    Over­all, thank you for your feed­back and com­ments. We pay atten­tion to your feed­back and we will make sure to improve the qual­ity of our work in 2010.

  23. Sander Baumann

    Thank you Vitaly Fried­man (editor-in-chief of Smash­ing Mag­a­zine) — very much for tak­ing the time to respond, very appre­ci­ated. I hope peo­ple can see beyond the form of the book and con­cen­trate on its great con­tents, a true added value for the design and web-development community.

    Thanks again and good luck, I’m sure it will be a Smash­ing 2010 for you and the team, keep it up!

  24. Alex Blundell

    Thanks Vitaly Fried­man for your thourough reply, Regard­ing the cost if the book I actu­ally agree with you. I have just moved house and had the book been much more expen­sive I would have defi­nately thought twice about buy­ing it. Put it into per­spec­tive really!

    Thanks again

  25. Dan Grossman

    @kirkoconnor That’s NOT a Google phrase! It pre­dates Google’s existence.

  26. Robin Parduez

    I got the book but I haven’t started read­ing it yet. After flick­ing through the pages, it looks pretty good, but I totally agree with oth­ers that the book is too small for this type of con­tent and it’s not easy to lay on a table next to your com­puter if you want to fol­low examples.

  27. Rizwan Reza

    I’ve also reviewed this book on my blog: http://rizwanreza.com/2010/01/08/the-book-that-smashed-my-expectations.

    I do agree with what you say, but I thought of a bet­ter book from them. I know they’ve done a fab­u­lous job with con­tent and lay­out, but a design book should be everlasting.

  28. […] I hope SM will con­tinue the con­cept of bring­ing the con­tent by book.” — Sander Bau­mann, Designworkplan“The book is basi­cally all of SM’s best arti­cles con­densed into a book. This is what you’d […]

  29. […] “The Smash­ing Book is a great, really great book for every­body who is inter­ested in design and web-development. Espe­cially the typog­ra­phy and learn­ing from the experts chap­ters where inspi­ra­tional resources to me. The con­tent is great but I believe the lay­out of the pages should be as a book. Sup­port the Smash­ing Mag­a­zine Book by order­ing your copy and I hope SM will con­tinue the con­cept of bring­ing the con­tent by book.” — Sander Bau­mann, Designworkplan […]

Leave a Reply